Whether your boyfriend is Don Draper or just thinks he is, you have to respect a man who knows what he wants. The trouble is, men who know what they want usually already have it. Your job is to figure out what he doesn’t know he needs. But what to give a classy modern gentleman with an eye for old-fashioned style?

Plus: The Ultimate Holiday Dating & Relationships Survival Guide

Shake Rattle and Roll Cocktail Shaker – Izola

Left and Right Cufflinks – Kate Spade

Plus: What to Get: The Person You’re Casually Dating

Jensen Wood Turntable – Urban Outfitters

The Gentleman’s Guide to Cocktails by Alfred Tong

Plus: The Perfect Gifts for Your Cheese-Obsessed Boyfriend or Girlfriend

The Panorama iPhone Lens – Photojojo

20 In Carryall In Leather

BillyKirk 20 inch Leather Carryall – Need Supply